Homemade Tomato Soup

Homemade tomato soup that’s loaded with delicious flavor, and uses common pantry items you probably already have. A quick and comforting recipe to serve as an appetizer or paired with a crispy grilled cheese sandwich.

Homemade Tomato Soup

One of my ultimate comfort foods

Mastering a classic tomato soup is all about keeping the ingredients simple, but focusing on technique. The red delicious fruit has a sweet but earthy taste that should shine through the dish. To elevate the flavors, I saute the savory aromatics like garlic, onion, and herbs before adding in the whole tomatoes to add depth and complexity.

Using ripe whole canned tomatoes makes it easy to crush and control the thickness of the soup. Customize the consistency by making it smooth and silky for a gourmet starter, or keep some larger chunks for a rustic appearance. And just like my tomato basil soup, this version can be enjoyed the same day or made ahead of time for a convenient healthy meal.

Homemade Tomato Soup

Use whole tomatoes

Canned tomatoes are a convenient pantry option to make this soup year-round. There are several different types of products to choose from, however, the whole peeled variety is best for this recipe. They have a balance of sweetness and acidity and crush easily.

I use a potato masher to break them down into smaller pieces before simmering and pureeing. You can also use your hands to squeeze and break them apart like my grandma used to do. This is where you have the flexibility to create a smoother of chunkier soup. For a smoky charred soup taste, use roasted tomatoes.

Add depth with alliums

To build a rich flavorful base, saute the onion and garlic in olive oil. Chopping the onions and using minced garlic releases strong sulfur-compounds that add depth to the soup. Lightly browning the onions naturally enhances the sweetness, while mellowing out the strong aromas into earthy notes. All of these ingredients infuse nicely into the vegetable stock.

Homemade Tomato Soup

Sprinkle in some herbs

Take advantage of dried herbs and add some Italian seasoning. The blend is typically a combination of oregano, basil, marjoram, rosemary, and thyme, so you don’t have to individually source each one.

If you have fresh herbs, feel free to use them. Simply add 3 times the dried amount listed, about 1 ½ teaspoons. Blooming these herbs in oil releases more fat-soluble flavor compounds, adding even more essence to the soup as it simmers.

Let it simmer

Once all of the ingredients are added to the pot, give it 15 minutes to simmer. Gently cooking the soup evaporates some of the water and concentrates the tomato flavor. This also gives the vegetables and seasonings time to merry together for a more gourmet taste. Here’s a little secret, the soup reheated the next day actually tastes better because the ingredients have even more time to infuse throughout the liquid base.

Homemade Tomato Soup

Puree the soup

There are two options for breaking down the tomatoes to its final slurpable form. The first is to use a handheld immersion blender directly in the pot to process and puree the soup. Make sure to submerge the blender head completely and then move it around the entire pot. This will give a chunkier, more rustic texture.

For a more refined, super creamy, and smooth consistency, use a blender. Remove the center plastic piece on the lid, then cover with a towel to let the steam escape without making a huge mess. You may need to work in two batches.

How to make a creamier consistency

Pureeing the tomatoes with a blender creates a smooth mouthfeel when processed down into small suspended particles. However, if you want a little more richness, add in some heavy cream right before serving. You don’t need to simmer as it can curdle. Just add 1 tablespoon at a time, then season with salt and pepper to taste.

Popular pairings

Serve this savory tomato soup with a classic grilled cheese sandwich. For a lighter lunch, make a crisp greek salad or creamy caesar salad. For heartier fare, pair it with a loaded baked potato. Make a stunning roasted chicken and enjoy the soup as an appetizer.

Homemade Tomato Soup

Substituting other canned tomato products

Crushed tomatoes are already broken down so there are fewer texture options for the final soup, but it’s a quick swap. A puree is often added to make it thicker, therefore you may need to thin out the soup with more stock. Diced tomatoes can be used, but often have calcium chloride added to the can to keep the pieces firm. Skip the mashing step and use the blender to break them down later.

Leave a Comment